Nexus 5 performance over screen size importance

#

We are still none the wiser as to when Google will release the Nexus 5, but we do know that when it comes to its screen size consumers would rather not have a larger screen device, as they feel performance is more important to them.

With this in mind, that means LG, Motorola, Sony, or whoever else is going to partner Google in making the device will need to consider this fact. There are some handsets on the market that have no place being there, such as the Motorola DROUD Ultra, it just seems lost in the wilderness of other larger screen phones and so should never had been built in the first place.

Nexus 5 specs are so important to its success; okay, they could go down the Moto X route and try to be a game changer because of its customization, but we cannot see this happening โ€” especially if Motorola is involved.

If you had the choice would you sacrifice some specs so that you could have a larger screen, or is it just not that important to have such a large screen?

As to the Nexus 5 release, there could be a good chance that LG will still be making this device and those rumors of Motorola involvement has led to speculation that they will be working on the Nexus 4 version 2, which we already discussed.

The thought of a Nexus 4 v2 is an interesting one and is certain to get some negative feedback because they feel this will be lazy of Google, and could be going down the same route as Apple. For years Apple has been ridiculed for launching S versions of their iPhone, which as we know offers a minor update over its previous model.

How do you think the Android community will react to a Nexus 4 v2?

Comments

37 thoughts on “Nexus 5 performance over screen size importance”

  1. Reply
    newsjunkieintl says:

    It better NOT be another 4.7″ phone. That was so LAST year. This year, 5″ is the new 4″.

    Look at the 5.2″ 1080p LG G2. With Snapdragon 800 it BEATS everything else out there and with the super slim bezel, the overall dimensions are great. People WANT a big screen, they just don’t want a “big” phone. LG has the right idea. Shrink the bezel, make the screen bigger. Put in a fantastic CPU..

    1. Reply
      Bjnbenner says:

      I would agree with you, but every other Nexus device on the market is named after it’s screen size, not it’s generation. Why would they make this any different for the phone Nexus? Or, thinking of it in a different way, what happens in 2 years? We would be calling the Nexus phone the Nexus 7.

      1. Reply
        antwan says:

        I dont understand why apple has stuck with numeric naming for phones but iPad, iMac etc for its other products, without numeric generation identifiers…Its less confusing to give it a proper name! Or call everything by its product title ONLY, and append the year in brackets on storefront marketing etc.
        I don’t know…

        1. Reply
          rs98 says:

          100% agreed; it’s just not the smartest thing to be calling one iPad the iPad 3 and the next the “New iPad”. What happens when it’s no longer the newest?

      2. Reply
        newsjunkieintl says:

        By the time we get to the gen 7 Nexus phone, Google will clarify/change their naming system. ๐Ÿ™‚

        But right now, considering the Nexus 4 was NOT the first 4″ Nexus but was the GEN 4 Nexus, that is the most logical reason it’s called the Nexus 4. Also, they used the generation name in the 1st Nexus, so there’s prior example.

  2. Reply
    stinkyfeet says:

    I just hope we have specs to compete with the Ones and the Galaxies under $400. They managed to do that last year. I don’t care what size the screen will be just nothing below 4.5″.

    1. Reply
      newsjunkieintl says:

      For the last two years, Google Nexus phones have been over 4.5″. They aren’t going smaller. Up to now they go larger, responding to market trends for top tier Androids. This year most of the top tier Androids are at least 5″ with 1080p display.

  3. Reply
    GUEST says:

    4.7″ is plenty for a phone. If I wanted a tablet, I’d buy one. Personality, I don’t think the extra “0.3 to “0.5 of screen size is worth sacrificing one handed use functionality.

    1. Reply
      newsjunkieintl says:

      You aren’t REALLY holding the screen, you are holding the overall phone. The solution is NOT to limit the screen size but to shrink the bezel so you can expand the screen to larger size without making the overall phone larger.

      For instance, Sony makes the Xperia Z and the Xperia ZL with THE SAME 5.0″ 1080P display. Yet, the ZL is a more compact phone. They slimmed the bezel more on the ZL. Read that again. Sony Z and ZL have SAME CPU, SAME RAM, SAME CAMERA, SAME 5.0″ 1080p DISPLAY — but the ZL is a SMALLER “5-inch” phone.
      ______
      Z: 5.47 x 2.80 x 0.31 inches (139 x 71 x 7.9 mm)

      ZL: 5.18 x 2.75 x 0.39 inches (131.6 x 69.8 x 9.8 mm)
      ________
      So, if the Google did that with a 5.2″ display phone, making the OVERALL dimensions be about the same as the 4.7′ display Nexus 4, you would have nothing against a bigger screen, as long as the overall dimensions stayed about the same? Right?

      Oh, look at this!

      _________

      5.2″ LG G2: 5.45 x 2.79 x 0.35 inches (138.5 x 70.9 x 8.9 mm)

      4.7″ Nexus 4: 5.27 x 2.70 x 0.36 inches (133.9 x 68.7 x 9.1 mm)

      ___________
      The G2 is a little taller, but only 0.09″ wider and only 0.01″ thicker. For comparison a U.S. nickel is 0.08 thick. Because LG really shrunk the bezel, due to new technology, they are putting a 5.2″ 1080p screen AND Snapdragon 800 CPU in a case about the same width and thickness as last year’s 4.7″ 720p LG Nexus 4. Why wouldn’t you want that?

      IF Google took the LG G2 as the blueprint for the Nexus 5, that is what you could expect.

  4. Reply
    GeorgeB says:

    I don’t understand why the writer knows that we don’t want a big screen. I for one am hoping for the nexus 5 to be based on the LG G2 at 5.2 inches. I’d rather not sacrifice any performance either. Why can’t we have both?
    The only thing I hope if it is LG is that we don’t get another glass back as on the Nexus 4.
    Of course this time around it also needs to be LTE.
    The truth is however that there are so many rumours and no one really knows who’s going to build it or what the specs are. Google’s good at keeping a secret. I for one can’t wait!

  5. Reply
    mjpado says:

    5 inch “Nexus 5” to go with Android 5.0 on Android’s 5th birthday. I’ll put money where my mouth is. Done.

  6. Reply
    flombusromtub says:

    5 inch display for the Nexus 5 would be perfect. I currently use the Samsung Galaxy Player WiFi-only device with a 5 inch screen and it is just the right size for me. I will also use the Nexus 5 as a WiFi-only device.

  7. Reply
    hguidwa says:

    I still feel 4.7 in is the perfect size. The v2 thing for Google is COMPLETELY different than apple, eg Nexus 7 v2

    1. Reply
      newsjunkieintl says:

      No, 4.7″ display is NOT the “perfect size” screen. What you mean is the Nexus 4 overall dimensions are good for you. Think about it…

      You aren’t REALLY holding the screen, you are holding the overall phone. The solution is NOT to limit the screen size but to shrink the bezel so you can expand the screen to larger size without making the overall phone larger.

      For instance, Sony makes the Xperia Z and the Xperia ZL with THE SAME 5.0″ 1080P display. Yet, the ZL is a more compact phone. They slimmed the bezel more on the ZL. Read that again. Sony Z and ZL have SAME CPU, SAME RAM, SAME CAMERA, SAME 5.0″ 1080p DISPLAY — but the ZL is a SMALLER “5-inch” phone.

      ______

      Z: 5.47 x 2.80 x 0.31 inches (139 x 71 x 7.9 mm)

      ZL: 5.18 x 2.75 x 0.39 inches (131.6 x 69.8 x 9.8 mm)

      ________

      So, if the Google did that with a 5.2″ display phone, making the OVERALL dimensions be about the same as the 4.7′ display Nexus 4, you would have nothing against a bigger screen, as long as the overall dimensions stayed about the same? Right?

      Oh, look at this!

      _________

      5.2″ LG G2: 5.45 x 2.79 x 0.35 inches (138.5 x 70.9 x 8.9 mm)

      4.7″ LG Nexus 4: 5.27 x 2.70 x 0.36 inches (133.9 x 68.7 x 9.1 mm)

      ___________

      The G2 is a little taller, but only 0.09″ wider and only 0.01″ thicker. For comparison a U.S. nickel is 0.08 thick. Because LG really shrunk the bezel, due to new technology, they are putting a 5.2″ 1080p screen AND Snapdragon 800 CPU in a case about the same width and thickness as last year’s 4.7″ 720p LG Nexus 4. Why wouldn’t you want that?

      IF Google took the LG G2 as the blueprint for the Nexus 5, that is what you could expect.

  8. Reply
    pure77 says:

    I would rather see LG make the Nexus 4 v2 and just update the phone, makes more sense. Moto needs to jump up and say i can rule once more with the Nexus 5.

    1. Reply
      Rambir says:

      Motorola need to release the Moto X outside North and South America. I was so looking forward to it and now I can’t get it because i don’t want to buy a contract I would be unable to use…

      1. Reply
        newsjunkieintl says:

        A 4.7″ 720p phone is nothing in 2013, when all 2013 top tier Androids have 1080p and almost all are 5.0″ – 5.2″. The 5.2″ 1080p LG G2 with quad core Snapdragon 800 (which beats everything else on the market) and 720p 4.7″ dual core Moto X were officially announced within 7 days of each other, and the G2 makes the Moto X look pitiful. Oh, but it has such pretty colored cases! The Moto X was hyped so much, but is a mid-range phone with an expensive price.

        1. Reply
          Rambir says:

          The LG G2 fits some niches, but not mine. Also, an 8 core device is far from mid-end and the LG G2 will probably lag more and will obviously have less features, and in worried about battery life. On screen size, that is preference, 4.7″ is good for me, and anything more doesn’t feel comfortable. 1080p screens are horrible for battery life and thermal throttling, and I would prefer the custom made soft touch back of the Moto X to the cheap plastic of the G2, I hated my Nexus S feel with the plastic. And finally, the human eye struggles to notice a difference between 300PPI and 400PPI without a direct comparison, and I doubt that you will carry both and stare at them. Specs aren’t everything, optimisations are.

  9. Reply
    khanman says:

    would rather have a 4.5 inch screen + with good specs than oppostite, atleast that way ik itll fit in my pocket

        1. Reply
          newsjunkieintl says:

          No, he said 4.5″. He said he wants 4.5″ screen plus good specs. I don’t read that as 4.5″+ screen.

          1. Rambir says:

            If he had said 4.5 ” + good specs, you would be right, but because if the word with, he says he wants a 4.5″ + and he also wants good specs.

          2. newsjunkieintl says:

            Either English is not your first language or you went to a poor school who did not teach writing. ๐Ÿ™‚ IF he had said what YOU think wrote, it would be “4.5+ screen with good specs”, instead he wrote “4.5” screen + with good specs” — which means 4.5″ screen plus with good specs”. Especially since he ALSO said he wants it to FIT IN HIS POCKET. He wants it 4.5″ or SMALLER. No other way to interpret it. Sorry, you are wrong.

          3. inspire says:

            I’d be inclined to agree with ‘newjunkieintl’, It would make more sense to read as…. would rather have a 4.5 inch screen + (plus) with good specs than oppostite, atleast that way ik itll fit in my pocket.

            4.5inch screen plus with good specs….

            if he mean larger screen I think he would have written…

            4.5inch + screen with good specs….

            the poster has confirmed ‘that way ik itll fit in my pocket’… unless he means mean a smaller phone wont fit into his pocket there is only one way to read that sensibly.

            i guess if the OP would just lay another post to clarify this, we wouldn’t need to speculate.

  10. Reply
    cpawiz says:

    I think 4.7″ is big enough. Performance over size. I want a phone that will comfortably fit in my pocket and if you get a case, then that adds some bulk and size as well.

    1. Reply
      Ugslick says:

      According to reports, the Nexus 5 has a 4.96 inch screen, but the phone itself is several millimeters smaller than the Nexus 4 in both length and width. LG’s really cut off the bezel in the G2 and Nexus 5..

  11. Reply
    Ian says:

    I would be happy with a Nexus 4 Version 2. I like the current LG Handset. Don’t know why?? I ditched my iPhone 5 for it and have been more than happy. (Well storage is an issue as had 32Gb iPhone and the camera isn’t as good.)

    To make it perfect throw in a faster more efficient processor, up the screen resolution, a bigger battery, 32Gb+ of storage 4G and an upgraded camera and I would be a happy bunny with the current shell ๐Ÿ™‚

    1. Reply
      Rambir says:

      4G is certain, on all bandwidth, because they just need to use the same radio in the Nexus 7, and that means all mobile carriers LTE and HSDPA+ in one, they must do 16GB and 32GB as they’re the obvious and commonplace, inclusing nexus, and they said that the next Nexus would have a great camera. I just hope that it is a G2 in a Nexus shell (slate with curved edges and the volume on the left and power on the write with no buttons on the face) and to tie things up, a new version of android, whether that be 4.4, doubtful, or 5.0, likely, then with a 4.7 to 5.02 inch screen, and inside a snapdragon 800 at 2GHz, an Adreno 325 GPU and 2 or even 3GB DDR3LLM RAM and a sub ร‚ยฃ350 (around $430) price-tag and there is no point getting another phone, fact.

Live Comment

Your email address will not be published.